The subject of remarriage following divorce is one of the most complex and debated topics within biblical scholarship and pastoral counseling. When navigating the intersection of ancient scripture and modern relationship dynamics, it is essential to approach the text with a focus on historical context, the theological principles of covenant, and the overarching message of grace. By examining the primary passages in the Gospels, the writings of the Apostle Paul, and the broader context of the Old Testament law, one can construct a framework for understanding how these ancient principles apply to contemporary commitments.
The Foundations of Covenant and the Teaching of Jesus
To understand the biblical perspective on marriage and remarriage, one must first establish the biblical definition of marriage. Throughout scripture, marriage is depicted not merely as a legal contract but as a covenantal union—a binding promise made before God.
The Original Intent
In Matthew 19 and Mark 10, Jesus points back to the creation narrative in Genesis. When questioned by the Pharisees regarding the grounds for divorce, Jesus emphasizes that marriage was designed by God to be an unbreakable union. He famously states, “What therefore God has joined together, let not man separate.” This foundation is critical because it establishes that the ideal, as intended by the Creator, is lifelong commitment.
Jesus’ Explicit Teachings on Divorce and Remarriage
The primary texts that address the status of those who remarry are found in the Sermon on the Mount (Matthew 5:32) and the interaction with the Pharisees (Matthew 19:9). In these instances, Jesus suggests that whoever marries a woman who has been divorced commits adultery, with the notable exception of cases involving sexual immorality (porneia). These passages have historically caused significant friction for believers, as they seem to impose a strict prohibition on remarriage. However, theologians often highlight that Jesus was engaging in a critique of the loose divorce practices of his day, where men were discarding wives for trivial reasons. The teaching serves as a defense of the sanctity of marriage rather than a permanent rejection of individuals who find themselves in complex marital situations.
Pauline Theology and the Concept of Grace
While the Gospels provide the baseline for the ideal of marriage, the Apostle Paul offers practical, pastoral guidance for the early church in 1 Corinthians 7. His letters provide a more nuanced look at how the early Christians were to handle the reality of broken relationships and the possibility of new beginnings.
The Permission for Remarriage
In 1 Corinthians 7:15, Paul introduces the concept of the “believer not being enslaved” in cases where an unbelieving spouse deserts the marriage. He writes, “But if the unbelieving partner separates, let it be so. In such cases the brother or sister is not enslaved.” Many biblical scholars interpret this to mean that the deserted party is free to remarry, as the covenant has been effectively dissolved by the actions of the departing spouse. This passage is significant because it recognizes that there are scenarios—such as abandonment—where the faithful party is not held responsible for the dissolution of the union and, therefore, is not prohibited from seeking a future partnership.
Addressing the Complexity of Human Failure
Paul’s approach is fundamentally pastoral. He recognizes that the reality of a fallen world includes the failure of marriages. His instructions often prioritize the avoidance of further sin (sexual immorality) and the promotion of peace within the body of believers. By providing these parameters, Paul acknowledges that while divorce is never the desired outcome, life within the grace of God does not end when a marriage concludes. His writings suggest that the church is tasked with holding to the high standard of covenant while simultaneously providing a pathway for those who have experienced the pain of divorce to live lives of integrity and faith.
Interpreting “Porneia” and the Context of Hardness of Heart
A recurring point of study for those researching this topic is the specific Greek term used by Jesus: porneia. Understanding this word is essential to interpreting the exceptions Jesus provided regarding divorce and subsequent remarriage.
Defining Sexual Immorality
Porneia is a broad term that covers various forms of sexual immorality. In the context of first-century Jewish marriage law, many scholars argue that this refers to marital infidelity or even prohibited unions. When Jesus allows for divorce under the condition of porneia, he is acknowledging that the covenantal bond has already been breached by the sexual betrayal of one partner. This breach essentially breaks the foundation of the marriage. Therefore, the subsequent marriage of an innocent party is often viewed not as an act of adultery, but as a recognition of a bond that was already severed by the actions of the spouse who violated the marital vows.
The Hardness of Human Hearts
Another vital element in the biblical narrative is the “hardness of heart” mentioned in Matthew 19:8. Jesus acknowledges that Moses permitted divorce because of the people’s stubbornness. This is a crucial insight for the modern reader: the Bible recognizes that humans are flawed and that marriages will end due to the selfishness and failure of sinful individuals. The focus of the biblical text is less about creating a legalistic checklist for remarriage and more about calling people back to the holiness and sacrificial love that make a marriage thrive. When marriage is viewed through the lens of human frailty, the focus shifts from a rigid “yes or no” to a question of restoration, repentance, and the potential for a fresh start.
Navigating Modern Pastoral and Personal Application
Applying these ancient texts to a 21st-century context requires a balance of scriptural fidelity and compassionate wisdom. It is rarely helpful to view these passages in isolation, divorced from the themes of redemption that permeate the rest of the Bible.
The Role of Repentance and Restoration
For many, the question of whether to marry a divorced woman is personal and deeply spiritual. If one is considering such a commitment, the biblical emphasis is often on the state of the heart and the character of the individuals involved. Repentance for the failures of the past, healing from the trauma of a previous divorce, and a genuine commitment to the covenantal nature of marriage are the marks of a relationship that honors God. The Bible does not treat the divorced person as an untouchable entity; rather, it provides a structure for living honestly before God, even when the past is marked by disappointment.
Focusing on the Future Union
Ultimately, the biblical perspective on marriage, regardless of the prior history of the participants, is rooted in the idea of the “one-flesh” union. Whether marrying someone who has been divorced or entering a first marriage, the goal is to cultivate a relationship that reflects the self-sacrificial love of Christ for the church (Ephesians 5:25). Rather than spending excessive time evaluating the past legalities of a divorce, many pastors today emphasize the importance of preparing for the current covenant. They encourage couples to ensure that they are entering the marriage with a commitment to faithfulness, communication, and mutual submission.
The Bible provides a high standard for marriage, underscoring the beauty and strength of a permanent, lifelong commitment. It also, however, provides grace for those who have experienced the breakdown of that commitment. By acknowledging the circumstances of abandonment or sexual infidelity, and by emphasizing the power of God to redeem broken paths, the scriptures offer a path forward for those seeking to build a new, healthy, and honorable life together. In this view, marrying a divorced woman is not inherently forbidden in the sight of God, provided the individuals involved are seeking to live in accordance with His principles of truth, love, and the restoration of a holy union.
aViewFromTheCave is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. Amazon, the Amazon logo, AmazonSupply, and the AmazonSupply logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates. As an Amazon Associate we earn affiliate commissions from qualifying purchases.